Baking it Down with Sugar Cookie Marketing 🍪

277. Baking it Down - First Timer Follies

Heather and Corrie Miracle Season 14 Episode 17

Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.

0:00 | 1:20:04

Send us Fan Mail

🤡 First Timer Follies - When you’re new and need orders.


In this week's Baking it Down Podcast - Episode 277 - First Timer Follies, we're wrapping up our New Baker's series, talking about first-timer mistakes you don't have to repeat if you snag yesterday's episode.

When you're new to any industry, it's easy not to know what ya don't know - and that's what this beginner podcast series is for: to help new bakers miss the missteps when just getting started, saving them time (and tears). 

You can reference the series here:

  • 🎧 277. Baking it Down - First Timer Follies
  • 🎧 276. Baking it Down - How To Turn Down Orders When You Need Orders
  • 🎧 275. Baking it Down - Big Shoes Battle
  • 🎧 274. Baking it Down - Allow Us to be Your Personal Yodas
  • 🎧 273. Baking it Down - Content Cookies for Beginner Bakers
  • 🎧 270. Baking it Down - The Right Foot when Getting Started
  • 🎧 269. Baking it Down - Sugar Cookies as a Side Hustle

🙅‍♀️ Don't overbuy cookie cutters

Corrie said a big impulse when you're first out of the gate is to snag each and every cookie cutter, dreaming of a certain style of baker you want to be, typically centered around a specific aesthetic. 

But it's your skill set and your client base that determines which cutters you'll find yourself reaching for most. So start with purchasing simple shapes and plaques - these are versatile shapes you can use again and again.

Oftentimes, bakers will end up never even touching the very cutters they spent their early dollars on - and that's a profit problem. Take notes from the folly of your elders - not every cutter is worth the squeeze when you're just getting started!

🙅‍♀️ Don't jump on trends

Trends are as awesome as they are a risk - you can make quick money, sure, but you can also be stuck with an endless supply of Labubu boxes or Target crates. Let the more established bakers snag those trendy sales - they have the audience for it and the skills for quick turnaround (before the trend dries up). Focus on popular (repeating) holidays at Christmas or Halloween that are guaranteed to come back in style year after year (and use up that extra pumpkin-shaped packaging). 

🙅‍♀️ Have an order intake form in place

With Google Forms being free and Jotform being essentially free for new bakers, you don't have to learn that you need an intake process in place by missing an order or spelling a name wrong. 

Take a lesson from every baker before you and make a form that gets all orders coming in to one place rather than managing texts, emails, Facebook messages, and Instagram DMs (it's only a matter of time before you miss some important detail that will force a refund or catch a bad review).

🙅‍♀️ Don't offer everything

You may feel like offering everything everyone wants will get you every dollar they have. Fun surprise - it actually works the opposite. Analysis paralysis + loss aversion + expiring ingredients = offering everything when you're just getting started can be bad news for profit margins. 

Start with the basics, master that, grow the customer base, then add the cake pops + bronuts + sourdough, etc. When you're just getting your sealegs under ya, it's not the time to be adding more boats to the fleet.

👂 Snag this podcast on any major podcast player (Spotify, Apple Music, Audible, Amazon Music, or watch it on YouTube) by searching for Baking it Down Podcast - Episode 277 - First Timer Follies.

People on this episode